More work, more investment, but efficiency gains remain elusive for middle market
Hard work and technology investment are failing to translate into genuine productivity gains for many of Australia’s middle market businesses, with increased output often requiring additional resources.
Pitcher Partners’ latest Business Radar Report finds that just 54% of middle market businesses rate their operations as very efficient, although 73% say their efficiency has increased over the past two years.
Yet among businesses reporting improved efficiency, only 39% are producing more with the same resources or maintaining output with fewer resources. Another 43% have increased output by adding resources, while 16% are producing about the same with more resources.
Some 43% say improved output is coming because they are pouring in additional resources while 16% say they are going backwards, spending more and taking longer to do the same or less than two years ago.
Pitcher Partners Melbourne Partner Gavin Debono said middle market businesses shared a commitment to operating more efficiently, but surveyed leaders pointed to a host of internal and external barriers that were holding them back.
Leaders lamented increased economic uncertainty, rising costs and tougher regulatory requirements as external barriers, while internal issues centred around people.
“Three-quarters of leaders reported barriers to efficiency that related to people, such as a lack or misalignment of skills, absence of training and poor collaboration across teams,” Mr Debono said.
“The results don’t point to an underperforming workforce, but to capable people operating in systems that make good performance harder.
“The leadership question should not be simply how to make people work harder. It should be about what prevents good people from making decisions, collaborating across teams, and completing work correctly the first time.”
Businesses that rated themselves as highly efficient were much more likely to empower people to make decisions and report better collaboration across teams.
Highly efficient businesses were also more likely to have simple organisational structures and describe leaders and management as effective.
Businesses that had not yet achieved their goal efficiency were less likely to have eliminated unnecessary work or processes, and believed they were less able to adapt to change.
Mr Debono said technology was often seen as a key factor that contributed to efficiency, but investment in areas like AI exposed a lack of similar attention in other areas.
While 65% of businesses had invested in technology, AI or automation over the past two years, only 13% had invested in leadership or organisational structure.
Given the strength of leadership, empowerment and collaboration in efficient businesses, this represented an opportunity to improve.
“You can’t simply buy your way to efficiency,” Mr Debono said.
“A new software tool or AI model has to align with a clear, strategic purpose and efficient processes. Your people also need the capability and training to actually use it effectively.”
Business Radar found business leaders were struggling to juggle all the demands on their time. Two-thirds reported increased management time was needed to run the business than two years ago, with a similar proportion said running the business required more effort and had become more complex.
Growth without better efficiency means more resources, operational complexity, compliance work and system friction, all of which consume leaders’ attention, the report found.
Anthony Kazamias, Partner, Pitcher Partners Brisbane said regulation changes were consuming management attention that could otherwise be direction towards productive activity.
“Many of the proposed Federal Budget changes have significant structural impacts on Australia’s tax regime,” he said.
“This is leading to interpretative and administrative complications creating great uncertainty and significant questions around those policies that have not yet been enacted.”
“This noise distracts business leaders from their productive undertakings.”
Pitcher Partners Business Radar surveys 300 owners and leaders of Australian middle market businesses across industries, states and growth stages. The latest report can be found here: https://www.pitcher.com.au/business-radar-2026/