Poor records prove costly for two taxpayers

By Peter Gillies - July 9, 2018

In two recent cases, taxpayers have failed to have assessments to income tax and penalties overturned because of a lack of documentary evidence to prove that the payments to them were loans and not income.


In both cases, the ATO issued assessments on the basis that payments that had been made to the taxpayers were income.  In the first case, the amounts paid to the taxpayer, Mr Rowntree, totalled more than $4 million over four years: in the second case involving Mr Hart, the total was approximately $500,000 in one year.  In addition to income tax on the amounts paid, the ATO imposed shortfall penalties of 50% of the additional tax on the basis that the taxpayers’ behaviour with respect to the tax treatment of the payments had been reckless.  In the case of Mr Rowntree, the penalty was increased to 70% for the last three of the four years involved.

In both cases, the taxpayers argued that the payments were loans.  While Mr Rowntree produced some documents (Division 7A loan agreements), the terms of the documents and dates they were executed were inconsistent with his argument (for example, as the loan documents only applied from a certain date and not to transactions before that date).  Mr Hart offered no documents to support his argument.  Further, the ATO had discovered material that Mr Hart had provided his bank in support of a loan application which supported the ATO case that the amounts were income.

Key takeaways

These cases highlight the importance of documentation and (equally) the importance of the timing of documentation. 

To the extent that loans are to be made by a company or trust, it is better to have those documents in place before the loans are made.  It is also important to ensure that the documents (in fact) cover the relevant transactions and that the documents are consistent with the substance of the arrangement.  The consequences for getting this wrong can be quite substantial.

Contact our experts

Other articles


Top of Page


Rob Southwell

Rob Southwell's picture


Managing Partner and Partner – Private Business and Family Advisory

> View profile

Nigel Fischer

Nigel Fischer's picture


Managing Partner - Private Business and Family Advisory

> View profile

Michael Minter

Michael Minter's picture


Managing Partner

> View profile

Leon Mok

Leon Mok's picture


Managing Director

> View profile

Brendan Britten

Brendan Britten's picture


Managing Partner and Executive Director/Partner- Business Advisory and Assurance

> View profile

Tom Verco

Tom Verco's picture


Managing Principal - Private Business and Family Advisory

> View profile

Partnership fraud


Paperwork and independent advice saves partnerships from fraud

Discover more

Kia Ora Horse Stud


Pitcher Partners fills a Financial Manager gap to keep the business on track

Discover more

Fuel Injection Company Administration


A fuel injection company began life as an Australian public company before being acquired by a UK publicly listed company while in the research and development stage of a “green...

Discover more

@PitcherPartner EXCELLENCE IN ENGINEERING | Our Newcastle & Hunter firm is proud to have sponsored the 2019 Hunter Business Chamber… https://t.co/cLBJmfJJBu